As close to ny style pizza as I've gotten in Cleveland so far. But it's got Los Angeles pricing and sometimes it can have that "zesty" sauce which I don't like. But the crust was perfect! And normally that's where pizzerias go wrong. This Dewey makes pizza crust light and chewy like it ought to be. Now if you can get that overdose of oregano and black pepper out of the sauce we are gonna be in 4 star territory! However the LA pricing and the zesty sauce brings us to a 3 star. Sorry I'm hyper critical of pizza so that's how I call it.
12/31/12 update - on a 2nd trip I asked for no added spices to the pizza- she mentioned that the sauce would have some already - I said fine just dont add more. and the pizza came out perfect!! so that DID happen on the 3rd visit too (the tie breaker) so I now up this to four star - cuz while its not exactly NYC pizza its pretty close!