Went here for lunch with a friend last week. Agree that parking is kind of nightmare... however, once inside, the spacious wooden bar and well-trod wood floors felt warm and welcoming. We had the Green Goat pizza. The crust was a little burnt, but it was tasty nonetheless. I was still hungry a while later, so I had a cup of the clam chowder: very tasty, but a bit thin. I also had cheese curds. These were heavenly. The best I've had in Madison. Even the Ranch dressing was good, and I find Ranch usually repellent.
CONS: The wi-fi didn't work, and I needed it for the business I was there to conduct.
I felt like I was inconveniencing them when asking questions about the menu.
Hey, nobody is on all the time, eh? That's cool.
Lastly: I saw that they have clams and oysters on the menu, so I will definitely be back. Another Green Goat is also in my future. And one of those tequila drinks with jalapenos in it.