First off, I really hate waiting around for a table, so the fact that I go here even when they don't take reservations should tell you something. The Mr. and I have been here several times, weekends mostly, and I'm always up for their Friday fish fry. Can't remember which night (Tues, mayhap?) but Taco Night is also interesting, in a good way.
You must order whatever the drink special of the evening is- each time I've been amazed at old Wisconsin drinks I've never heard of before. Bartenders are attentive and friendly, the location's great and I've never had a bad meal or experience here.