I think these guys have the lowest prices in board games in the city.
I went online to try and find Dixit, and Amazon gives me $56 for the original version and Snakes and Lattes gives me $37. These guys sell it for $23.
Catan original and expansions sell here for $28.95, comparable at $40. And the 5-6 players (still a cash grab, but anyway) sells for $14.95 instead of $20.
In the small store, they have lots of board games, and some action figures. The main counterarea is Magic Card central, on the right, lots of action figures and collectibles. In the back are shelves and shelves of board games. D&D dominates one bookcase entirely.
I also emailed and called them, and they were really friendly about pricing and inventory.