The owner needs to update his Yelp page - they've change their name to Stanley Security Solutions. Regardless, this is the only place I go to have keys made. Just went in today to have keys made for a Suzuki motorcycle. They had the right blank in stock it was only around $5 per key. I also took in an obscure little key for a luggage box that they were able to copy as well. These guys also have a great selection of really high-end gun safes.
I also had them cut some blanks for my wife's Honda Odyssey last year (she lost very expensive key and fob). They had the machine to program the key to the vehicle and the cost was much less than the dealership. I bought the key blanks on eBay not realizing Stanley had them in stock for essentially the same price.
I've been in town long enough to remember when Liberty was further East on Sahara inside Liberty Plaza - a tiny location under the statue of Liberty.