AMAZING! The oysters on the half shell were fresh and delicious. The server was very knowledgeable in helping us pick them out from a wide selection of clams and oysters that ranged from Virginia to Prince Edward Island. We had the steamed mussels next which were SO delicious. And then the lobster roll was the best I've ever had - lobster meat was fresh and sweet, the roll was toasted and buttery.
They also had a great drink selection to pair with everything. The pricing wasn't ridiculously expensive, either! Merchant Oyster Co is a little oasis in the city - I totally felt like I was on vacation at the beach! We will definitely become regulars here.