It's not terrible but it's not great. They messed up our order and before I knew it, I was half way done my buddy's burger - the original BBQ cheese one when I really wanted to try the OFD. The patty was a tad on the small side and wasn't very juicy. In fact, it was a bit overcooked and didn't taste as fresh like some other gourmet burger places. The bun has some greasy layer on it, I prefer a more doughy bun to be honest. The topping selections for each burger were good though. Nice to have something unique like a Thanksgiving burger as an option, same with Turkey vs. Beef.
The atmosphere was like a sportsbar and it was packed with people on a Saturday night. You can tell people were excited to try out a new place. I'd say the quality is definitely above McDonalds but below say a Burger's Priest. Something in the middle, something average. I also had the sweet potato tots which were nice and a Sam Adams Boston Lager, which was also nice for a change. Prices were what one would expect for King West. I could eat here again but I won't be rushing back anytime soon. I could see out of town people eating here before/after a Jay game.