First, I would like to say the food was amazing. I had the New Zealand lamb, and it was the best lamb I have ever had in my life. I've eaten at a lot of high end restaurants across the country, and I can easily say that the lamb at Otto's is some of the best. I ordered it medium rare (as you should do if you are eating high quality meat) and it was cooked perfectly. It was served with a chimichurri that was delicious and had the perfect blend of herbs and gave a nice saltiness to the lamb.
We had the bruschetta and the cheese sampler plate for appetizers. Both of these were very good, and I would definitely order them again. The bruschetta had some sort of whipped feta (that's what it tasted like) that complimented the chopped tomatoes and olives perfectly. My wife had the Chilean sea bass and it was also really tasty.
The reason I give Otto's a 4 star review is because our service was sub-par. Our waitress was pretty cold towards us when she realized we weren't going to order alcohol. She never asked us if we needed anything or if our food was good. She came occasionally and filled our water and left. It just didn't feel like she really cared.
Overall our experience was good because I don't go to a restaurant just for the service. I go for the food and the food was phenomenal. If you want to have some lamb that knocks your socks off go to Otto's.