This location is currently being listed in my books as Needs Improvement for the time being as my visit last night just didn't live up to the high expectations that their original location has set in my mind.
For now, the pros are the location and the decor. They've really scored with this old pub they've taken over and converted into what looks almost like a mini German beer hall with long communal tables. They've really put a focus on making this place have it's own look and feel while maintaining some of the popular cool from the original - mission accomplished, I really love it. Also, the wrap around patio looks to be a superb addition.
Another pro was the appetisers we shared: poblano queso dip and Thyme fries. WOW! Between three of us, these starters were basically a main course. So cheesey and good was the poblano cheese with deep fried tortilla chips. And the cook and seasoning on the thyme fries was amazing.
The areas that need work were as follows and I don't plan to harp on them because I recognise that this place is newer and some kinks need to be worked out but without honest feedback from someone like me who IS a HUGE fan of D55, how will they improve? My plan is to return and reassess and upgrade this review:
- As others have mentioned they were understaffed and therefore service was spotty and slow. We waited long times at and betweene very step of service with some items not making it to the table at the same time
- Cocktails. I ordered the Old Fashioned, my favourite cocktail from their PC location and for some reason the Streetsville version did not match up. Within 2 sips it was already very watery
- Main courses. Brisket was over cooked and cold, as if it had been sitting for a while before service. The fried chicken did not fry properly or was over cooked and the batter fell right off the chicken upon being picked up. In addition, the chicken was ever seasoned and salty
As you can see there are 5 distinct points which if executed fully would warrant all 5 stars, currently I'd say they're around the 2 to 2.5 star range but all of the areas in need of improvement are totally and easily fixable.
I'm looking forward to returning here and re-experiencing Door 55 and giving them the 5 star review I know they deserve
Eatcrest Out