I've been to this little gem 4 times so far. Home run each time. Thus far, I've tried :
1. Pastrami sandwich
2. Cubano sandwich
3. Italian Beef sandwich
4. Reuben sandwich
These are typical choices for a NY deli but each one garners a perfection of taste and quantity that leave me in yum-struck wonder .
Top that off with the best chocolate chip cookie you can imagine (large enough for 4 people to share- not kidding), and you have the NYT deli. It's one of my new favorite lunches in all of Arizona.
On top of that, the staff is much more like a warm and helpful Midwest hospitality mind set than a typical NY in-your-face brashness, which I think is worth a an extra *star if I could add it to my rating. Who'd of imagined it - great NY food without the beastly NY attitude. Someone finally figured that one out ! Thankfully!