I've spent a bunch of time in NYC and tried quite a few bagel shops in Manhattan and Brooklyn. Gotham in Madison definitely holds their own. The texture and chewiness are right on. My mouth is watering right now thinking about my last Gotham sandwich - Spanish Harlem on Super Egg. The contrast and balance of smoky pulled pork, tart pickle, tangy mustard, creamy swiss, and salty capocollo inside the crispy/chewy bagel rocked my world. Best of all, the tender pulled pork has all the crunchy burnt bits and spice rub you find in authentic southern BBQ. Mmmm.... Keep up the good work Gotham!!!
note: this review pertains to the new Park Street store.