I've had two experiences here and overall they have been great. My mom came in from out of town and we wanted to take her somewhere local and cool for dinner so we chose the Market Garden Brewery. My mom even had a beer and she NEVER drinks beer. My mom and I went for the Wahoo Wit while her fiance and my boyfriend got the Wallace Tavern Scotch Ale. Mine was crisp and tasty while my boyfriend declared that the Scotch Ale was his new favorite beer. The food was good though I was kind of disappointed that I got the pierogies when I saw how good the burger looked. The pierogies were delicious, but seriously, that was one good-looking burger!
The atmosphere is great, the prices are reasonable, and I look forward to going back and trying the patio. The only complaint I have is with the growlers. We went back to get a growler of the Scotch Ale on a Saturday afternoon to take to a family get-together and we couldn't get any of the 4 people behind the bar to even make eye contact with us. We seriously stood there for at least 15 min. I understand it was busy with market-goers, but come on. A simple "be right with you" would have sufficed. We finally had to wave our arms around like lunatics to get service. Then they slapped us with an $8 to-go charge for the growler. Now, I assume that this is to offset the price of the bottle, but we weren't expecting it and almost decided not to go through with it, but we were already salivating for the Scotch Ale. I hope that I am right in assuming that if we bring the bottle back in to be refilled, we won't be charged the $8.