It seems Scruffy Murphy's isn't actually closed - it just moved a block down the street to 180 Eglinton Ave E in a building that once housed a Golden Griddle.
I stopped in for a lunch with adequate pub style results.
The menu is standard pub fare, and I went with the Scruffy Burger which is a cheeseburger with bacon and a fried egg on top for $13.99. It was a decent burger and the fries were okay too, no complaints.
The beer menu is standard macro brands with the Buds and Labatts of the world. Not impressive but they did have 2 craft beers on tap - Cameron's Ambear Ale and Captains Lager ringing in at a cool $5.50 (plus tax) per pint.
Service was kind of meh since the bartender was also serving tables, but I don't really have much to complain about so 3 stars seems right.
Here's hoping they put patio furniture outside as I walked by a few times in the summer and it always seemed weird to have a nice side street patio but not actually give people the chance to use it. I guess we'll find out next year?