My brother proudly hates this store. Yet almost every year when I buy him things from there for Christmas or his Birthday - he totally loves them. Every time.
As he's gotten a bit older there is less for him here except t-shirts, but during his 13-16 years this was the ultimate stop for his Christmas stocking. Funny t-shirts, buttons w/ funny sayings, cool notebooks, fun character stuff from the newest "cool" tv show. Even pencils with cool stuff on them. Once he found out where some of them were from because he said I shouldn't have even gone in there because he hates that store, but by that point he loved what I'd gotten him enough that it was assumed that must have been the ONLY cool think in there.
If you don't have a teenager, or someone who lives at least a part of their life like a teenager, don't bother to go in the store. But for those who love Family Guy, feel a little goth or emo now and then or just want to find a cool band concert shirt so they'll be hip with the ladies - this isn't an all bad place to go.