Believe this hype: this might be the best pizza in the country. I've had pizza all over New York and New Jersey and this joint may top them all.
There were three of us and we ordered three pizzas (one red, two white) which ended up being just the right amount with a few slices left over for later. The red pie had salami and olives, one of the whites, delicious grilled onions, spicy sausage and mozzarella (we asked for them not to grill it as it usually comes) and the last white with mozzarella ricotta and arugula. They were all absolutely superb. All the ingredients were perfect and the crust was just divine. I went last night and I'm already to go back.
Yes, there is often a wait but there's a really awesome bar next door in a historic house. Go there and grab a drink on the porch while you wait.
Just come here - you won't regret it.