I'm lucky that I get to travel for a living and I use my Yelp App to seek out great beer spots. In the last year I have over 150 hotel nights in fourteen states. So I've had a chance to visit a tremendous number of great beer joints!
My Holy Grail is the big three- A great beer selection, amazing gastro-pub food, and a bartender that looks like a Victoria's Secret model! I haven't found this mystical place yet but I'll keep trying.
Smokin' Joe's is one for three but it's the most important one and that's a great beer selection. What can I say; the tap list and the bottle list are both exceptional. The organization of the beer list itself is very good. Many less traveled folks would probably say five stars but I'm going for 4. The lists at the 5 star places include IBUs and a more extensive description of each beer. BTW, the beer prices are very competitive here.
As others have said, the food is hit and miss here. For me it was a miss. Actually I'm not even going to discuss it. I'm going to think of these folks as a four star beer place without a menu.
If you are a beer aficionado and in the Pittsburgh area, a visit here is a must. Just eat first and come here for the brews.