Carmen's is old-Toronto. I'm sure it was very popular back when doing out for a dinner meant something more than wearing your best LaCoste golf shirt with the collar popped. Sadly, this time is no more and Carmen's has really fallen by the wayside and clearly been unable to keep up with the times.
The service and the food was excellent but atmosphere and waiters are almost gimmicky. I realize it used to be a very formal place but I think you can keep the classic ambiance and still update a little. The silverware and flatware are all pitted and likely as old as I am. Same goes for the Menus, what are they doing with these. You really just need to see these books, I mean, menus.
When I attended on Wednesday evening there was only one other party in the restaurant. Not exactly a happening spot anymore.
Regardless, I would like to go back on a Friday or Saturday. It would be nice to see if its busy on the weekend. You might even be able to wear a suit and tie at this place without getting the stare down from other patrons with confused looks on their face.