Murray Hill Market gets 5 stars for their amazing personable service and neighborhood feel. My team met there for a lunch meeting. The owner is so super friendly and enthusiastic about their food, and their food is GOOD. She gave me a few samples of their freshly grilled fish so I could see what I might like for a sandwich. I loved their salmon as well as their crusted tilapia. I ended up with the crusted tilapia sandwich, but will go for the salmon next time! They also feature local goods, like Little Italy pasta sauce as well as Polish desserts (called snoogle.)
This place is perfect for outdoor patio hangouts and meetings. There is a small space on the upstairs level with a table, but it's not for large parties. I'm definitely coming back while the weather is still nice.
I appreciate this market overall for their focus on local & fresh goods and their friendly service!