I hate this dump. The only nice thing about it is the large outdoor area, which is pretty nice and unique for a bar of this size. You can even drive your boat up and get some booze if you like.
I will say my experiences with the Rusty Rudder always came at night for the bar, so I can't really speak for the food or anything else. I generally hate the crowd that always comes here, and every time I've been someone always ended up getting in a fight (granted, it was often one of my friends, but still).
The drinks are overpriced and watered down. The bathroom is a complete mess. I think this place just needs an overhaul. They have one of the best spots on the lake, if they would just class it up it could be quite nice.