I am usually wary of trying out Italian restaurants (espc. Little Italy fare); if the food isn't done right I always end up thinking: Why did I waste money on something that I could've made at home! Ergo, warily I sought out Caffino.
Like Colleen mentioned, Caffino is a charming and intimate place. It's simply decorated; the candelabras with melted wax,resembling stalactites, caught my eye. Added to the romantic flair.
Our server was very friendly, attentive and knowledgeable. I ordered the Penne a la Puglia which was delicious: very flavorful, fresh and filling. My friend ordered the Margherita pizza which was equally great: no complaints at all. We split a cheesecake for dessert and were clutching our stomachs after, we were very happily full!
I really enjoyed my experience at Caffino: it's intimate enough for you to have a private conversation without bumping elbows with other patrons; and the food and the service are worth ever penny (they could even get away with charging more). Caffino is fantastico!