The three cheese pizza with black olives and onions from Ohio City Pizza is my favorite Cleveland pizza. Even better if you add bacon to the order.
I recommend ordering for pick up for two reasons.
1. you get to talk to Birdie who is often the one making you pizza. Even though another reviewer referred to her as a pirate, I have always found her to be friendly and fun.
2. sometimes they overcook pizzas but that doesn't seem to happen when you pick it up on time.