This review is mostly for brunch because I think it's what they really excel at. I've had dinner here once and I think it was good... but a little unmemorable. The brunch, on the other hand is awesome.
Their eggs benedicts are really delicious, especially the artichoke, which is my favorite. My most recent visit I got the crab cakes and I didn't love it, but the sauces and creamy and very tasty. If you like sweets, I highly recommend the Bananas Foster French Toast - it's unbeatable! My boyfriend literally said, "I can never finish 4 pieces of French toast except here." They're that good. The cheese grits are a nice side with anything. I don't love their potatoes because they're very creamy and heavy.
They have nice seating outside if you happen to be in Madison during the 3 months when it's warm enough to consider it. Make sure to make reservations for Sunday brunch - they get very busy.