Their tap beer selection was outstanding, unfortunately that's about the only positive thing I can say. Their BBQ sauce (which most BBQ lovers know can make or break your restaurant) was extremely watered-down, service was average at best and their food was just OK overall. It seems like they're trying to go gourmet with BBQ, which in my opinion isn't working for them. Smoky Jon's is still the only place you can get "real" BBQ in Madison.