Found this place from Yelpers, and they were right (well, most of them). We had a fantastic meal (actually 2) and it was pretty darn cheap. I admit, I had a bit of envy when my girlfriends chicken gyro came out - but I just stole some so it worked out.
In fact, if we didn't want to try so many different restaurants we would have visited again before we left town. This was definately the best part of staying at that part of town.