Many year ago, all my shoes used to come from Aldo so that's where the 3 stars come from. I like how they are trendy but still offer classic styles like the stiletto that won't be outdated after one or two seasons. I also love their colours, bags and accesories.
As for the -2 stars:
1) their prices have gone up and their quality has gone down. I think the material of their shoes is crappy and really hard and make for tons of blisters
2) I once got an infection from wearing a pair of ballet flats for a half an hour walk from Union station to Queens Park..I had to take antibiotics and my ankle swelled up! I really should take more than 2 stars away just for this..but I won't cause i think i'm nice..
3) my bags do not last for very long. The leatherish ones crack and the straps come off. I have a yellow one that is stained from the colours of my clothes!
So in general, if you're looking to spend close to $80-$90 on shoes that will hurt you and that are really uncomfortable, go for it..but if not, go check out winners..they have awesome shoes, better yet, Style Sense in Vaughn Mills!! *drools*