If I liked to hoard random stuff, this would be the place I'd go to do it. The Bag Lady is bubbling over with estrogen and new age-iness. Within the store is a variety of merchandise such as sarcastic magnets, silly gifts, stationery, books and jewelry. They even have a magic/wicken section (with ceremonial candles and tarot cards).
One thing I give super props for is the fact that they're really good about stocking items/crafts from local artists. I'll definitely keep this place in mind next time I need to spontaneously get someone a gift!