The muffuletta is so good that I almost never get around to trying the rest of the menu. Generous mix of olives and giardinera, thick layer of meats.
Last time in, my wife ordered the Italian sausage, said it was tasty, too (you might want to ask them to add provolone, though). I've had some of the salads, liked them all. There's a selection of cookies as well. I finally gave in to temptation and tried a few; it's going to be hard not to do that every time, now.
Everyone behind the counter is friendly and cheerful.
Highly recommended.