I really want to like the Pittsburgh Popcorn Company, but sadly I think it's overrated.
I took my friends from out of town here as I had read so many good things about it. When we got there, it was 15 minutes before the store closed, and there was a long line. My friends and I bought the peanut butter and chocolate, cinnamon toast and kettle flavors, and everything was good. Not spectacular though. I may be a little harsh, as I was going in with very high expectations. Or maybe we were not here on a week with very good flavors of the week.
The friendly, awesome guy behind the register who seemed like one of the owners, was very generous with the popcorn and stuffed the small paper bag up to the brim. With customer service like that, why wouldn't people come back??