One of those places you really wish there was a 3.5 star ranking...
But! Food leans me towards 4. We had the baja fries and the toppings were generous and deliciously gluttonous in the best way. Oysters were served on ice with lemon and horseradish to taste, as per usual. Lobster roll and Shrimp Po' Boy were both very, very good and fresh. We will definitely be back to sample more of the menu and try the specials. Wait staff and decor were both fun and accommodating!
Couple things lean me more towards 3. Music as Too Loud (I'm a senior citizen apparently), but mostly the beer menu. VERY SMALL selection. There's a hoppy local brew and Creemore Springs... maybe a couple more but nothing spectacular. Could stand to see a few more options but I'll round up.