Easily, a Madison favorite on the Square (great outdoor patio). I'm sure you already know about the coffee.. it's excellent.
Their baked oatmeal is terrific. I suggest ordering with yogurt instead of the milk. If you're looking for a dessert or treat, you can't go wrong with one of the brownies.
A minus star for turning off their WiFi on the weekends. I understand the reasoning (squatters).. but it's still a drag for those of us who want to do a little surfing while we enjoy our morning coffee. There are better solutions.