I really like this place! My boyfriend and I went because we had a coupon and it was delicious. The atmosphere was quaint and the staff was polite. I had the smothered trout with rice and vegetables. It was amazing and good size portion too. I probably would have had enough to take home if I hadn't been so hungry. I also stole a bite of my boyfriend's farfalle florentine and that was pretty tasty too. The night was topped off with a piece of tiramisu. I usually don't like tiramisu but I changed my mind after having it at City Tavern. This is definitely the place to go for a glass of wine or a casual dinner. It's classy but it isn't a place where you have to get dressed up. I plan on going back soon.