I was so excited to try this pizza place after my friend told me about it because it was hidden and it had amazing yelp reviews! But I was disappointed. It was a lot of fun to find and I love the concept of the the best kept secret, but this really is not what it is.
The service to start with was pretty shitty and probably discriminatory. My friend and I are in the service industry so we would never be one of those rude or extremely picky guests so I know it had nothing to do with our personalities. We witnessed guests in front of us receive friendly service from the cashier lady's good side. With us, she rolled her eyes and rushed us. I was prepared to let that go, given extremely good pizza.
Annnnd the pizza was okay. It was nothing to rave about. I might be bias because I favorite NY style pizza and this was just not close at all. The crust was plain, not enough sauce or cheese and the topping was okay.
It was a fun little hunt inside the Cosmo though, just wish the treasure tasted better.