Proper...I want to love you, but you have some work to do. Maybe I will up this at some point; but for now, it is a three star.
I have dined here once and sat at the bar three or four times. There is a lot that I love about the place. It's really pretty with a modern flair that is balanced by the old brick feel. The bar chairs are comfy (albeit a little hard to get into and out of because they are crammed in there). The bar list is excellent, with cocktails, beer, and wine sure to please anyone. The food has always been very good, but there are weird little annoyances. For example, they have a hummus platter (which is excellent); but it's served with a super-skimpy portion of pita (which is not excellent). I feel like they should have figure that whole thing out by now.
Service has been hit or miss, with mostly misses. On my most recent visit, it was not busy at all because it was still early. There were FIVE people behind the bar, yet our drinks were empty for at least 5 minutes until we finally caught someone's attention. That just shouldn't happen.