I'm bumping my rating up to 5 stars! With the recent reno, it's perfect. The pizza recipe hasn't changed, though they've added some fancy-schmancy toppings to what was a very basic selection previously. I love that they kept some old signage to authenticate the 50 year history of this place, and they salvaged the portion of the front window that contained the old, fading signage. It looks great as a divider between the back prep area and the seating.
Live on for another 50 years, DPH!