I think this place isn't for me. There are so many great reviews, my wife included, so this must just be me. I've been twice and, in my opinion, everything was just okay.
The facility is small and set up a little weird but I think they will eventually outgrow this place and move into a spot that will better suit how busy they are are. The service was a little slow but this place but bumping each time that I went.
The first time I went, I ordered the Drunken Sicilian: thick crust with mozzarella, vodka sauce and basil. In my opinion, it just wasn't very flavorful... the crust nor the sauce. Don't get me wrong, it was a decent pizza but just wasn't for me.
The second time that I went, I got the cheese ravioli in tomato sauce. I pretty much has the same experience.
Now... my experiences from a flavor standpoint haven't been out of the park but the service has always been okay and the place is kept up well. AND... I have heard that their stuffed shells and their calzones are bomb though.