Been wanting to visit for a while, and I've got to say, it was worth the trek!
The pizza here is really good and they use really fresh ingredients. We got two 'small' pizzas for three people, the Deluxe and Mediterranean, and we were completely stuffed. It was so much food.
Both of the pizzas had tons of really fresh ingredients on them. It shows in both the presentation and taste. The crust was really tasty and crispy at the bottom of the entire pie. Yum. However, I think they were both missing a little *something*.
There are a few tables inside, but most people just seem to do take out. Paoletti's pizzas are super hearty and super filling. Unless you really eat a lot of food, I think their portion recommendations are accurate (as in... ONE small pizza for three people, ha!).
Will definitely be back some time!