I checked out this Brewsters for the first time last night whilst bro-ing down with Angelo Ramirez. When we first walked in, it seemed a little too loud for philosophical conversations and beers which is why I initially wanted to avoid the Ship and the Hop. We also tried going to Regal Beagle first but I noticed they had spelled "karaoke" as "karoaki" on their window and snubbed them immediately thereafter.
The whole vibe of Brewsters is a little too post-GYM-TAN-LAUNDRY-picking-up-babes-while-watching-the-game-on-eight-tvs-at-once, but we managed to find a quieter spot at the back of the bar. Our server was really quite nice.
I ordered the blueberry ale, which is fucking fantastic. I am happy to report they put real blueberries into my beer which rules. I was actually very impressed to see all of their different brews on the menu. I saw that you can make any burger on the menu a lentil burger, but wasn't hungry. Worth scoping though. I was impressed by the fruity sampler that my aforementioned beer guzzling partner ordered, and its presentation.
It is definitely no Wild Rose as far as the atmosphere goes, and there are other bars within proximity I would visit first next time. However, I will probably be back to try a few more brews.