Went here for the first time in years. I knew what to expect. The square fish was how I remembered. I don't think it's bad. Tastes similar to filet o fish.
Fries were average at best. The most disappointing part of the meal was the shrimp. The review that said scraps of shrimp surrounded by 1 inch batter is correct. I have never seen shrimp this over battered in my life. By weight, they must be about 90% batter. It really borders on false advertising. And the coleslaw was a sloppy overdressed mess.
Pete's is an overpriced fast food restaurant, not a proper fish and chips establishment. Oscar's Pier 83 blows them away. Even Long John Silver's is much better than Pete's.
Bottom line, if you must go here. I only recommend ordering the fish. The shrimp is 90% bread.