As others have noted, this isn't the cheapest Italian you can get, but for those looking for heft per dollar spent, there's always East side marios.
Came here on a whim on a Friday night (about 7:30?) without reservations and we were seated fairly soon. Ordered the grilled calamari, seafood linguine and the ragu. My dining partner also ordered a glass of the Angel's Gate Riesling which she enjoyed. The calamari was great - nice grilled flavour and it was tender with just a little bite to it (as opposed to overly mushy chemically tenderized meat). I had the ragu which had a fantastic meaty flavour - it's a meat sauce with some tomato flavour as opposed to a tomato sauce with meat. I enjoyed it. And my partner thoroughly enjoyed the seafood linguine, noting that things were seasoned and cooked well.
I would recommend it for the great food that we had. Again, price isn't on the cheap side. And I have no issue with the noise. I did glance over at the table next to us at the lamb that was ordered; seems cooked more than I would like but perhaps he ordered it like that? It still looked good however.
I wish I could comment on the decor. I was there maybe 80 mins and focused on my companion and the Leafs/caps game on the tv once in a while. Still enjoyed the evening overall.
PS. The entrees came out a bit slower than I would have expected and if we were really hungry I think we wouldn't have been so kind. But the kitchen and the wait staff were definitely busy that evening and not being inefficient.