I am giving Our Place 3 stars overall. They have a good Reuben sandwich, but anything else we have gotten from here has been okay at best. We also have had much better experience when we get food to go (call in first or else you will be waiting awhile) than when we eat in.
The restaurant is dated in that it looks like the old Pizza Hut buildings from the 80's. The service when eating in has also been pretty slow and unfriendly. If we only had experience eating in and had not tried the Reubens we probably would never return. However when ordering and doing carryout on this single dish it is a good deal.
Other dishes I have had include fried chicken which was okay (still a three star out of five) and the pizza (I may have to dip to a one star out of five here). Based on experiences with those dishes I don't think I could try any other dishes for fear of extreme disappointment and wasted money. I definitely wouldn't recommend eating in, but if you want a decent Reuben to go this may fit the bill.