There is nothing incredible about John's Incredible Pizza. We wanted to take our 3 year old somewhere new today so we tried out John's. The price point was higher than I expected at $12.98 for adults with a drink. I was optimistic when I saw the 4 food buffets, but that didn't last long. Pizza is the obvious staple on a pizza buffet and it was all wrong. The pizzas at John's are cut 10 times instead of the standard 5 cuts for a medium pie. What you end up with are thin micro slices that are not fun to deal with. Another mistake is that the cutter did not cut all the way through to the ends so when you dish up a slice, all of the pieces stick together which again is not fun to deal with. Every single pizza was cut that way. All of the pizzas I tried were doughy and undercooked. One bite was all I could choke down of each pizza.
I decided to try some of the soups, figuring I could fill up on something before I go. The baked potato soup was watery and broken down because it had set on the buffet too long.
I moved on to the Fiesta soup and it was the exact same, watery and broken down. I thought ok, I'll try some salad bar and get my family out of this place. When I got to the salad bar, I noticed that all of the veggies were micro cut (Apparently that's a thing at John's). The tomatoes were diced too small and were breaking down into mush. The ham was the same way.
When I got back to the table my 3 year old spilled her water on the booth seat and some ice spilled on the floor. I tracked down a kid to help clean up the spill. When he came back with towel in hand he saw the ice on the floor and immediately went to get a mop instead of wiping off the booth first.
We had to stand there and wait another two minutes for him to return.
The food at John's is low quality. Be prepared to be underwhelmed if you try them out.