This place is legit. Gourmet Pizza with lots of beer options on tap.
I must say I was a skeptic when I read the menu and barely knew what half the ingredients on the pizza were. I thought this place was going to be a little too uptight for my taste. I was very wrong.
We stopped in before the Pirates game and much to our surprise we were seated immediately with a perfect view of the brick oven. They had one cook making all the pizzas which was very impressive (all members of my party commented on his difficult job). We had the Margherita Pizza (san marzano tomatoes / fresh basil / house mozzarella / extra-virgin olive oil) and the Forest Pizza (caramelized wild mushrooms / roasted shallot / balsamic reduction / fresh thyme / fontina). Some of the best gourmet pizza I've ever had. Absolutely delicious!
Loved the atmosphere and found the pizza to be exceptional. We all left big fans of The Proper and would be very surprised if I didn't return here soon.