First-timer, life-timer!!!
Went and played golf at Monona this past Friday and afterwards we were looking to grab some food, so my friend suggested Mickey's. I hadn't heard of it since I'm new to the area and don't get to Willy St., so didn't know what to expect. Boy, was I pleasantly surprised.
It's a complete dive bar from the outside, sort of your typical WI corner looking bar. Inside there's a ton of character from this old house turned bar/restaurant. It was the first night they opened the patio in the back so it was very busy. Our server was incredibly busy and I was a little taken back when they said they didn't even have any more Miller High Life, but they had plenty of others to choose from. Not a big deal. We did have to go the bar to order drinks at one point since our waitress wasn't anywhere to be seen.
But.... she did apologize and was very attentive the rest of the night. Again, just a busy night.
The Food: This is where Mickey's really shines!!
My friend had their burger which is rated the best in town, so says he and much of Madison. I had a green chile pork dish that is topped with Mozzerella and comes with tortillas. I have never tasted anything like it and thoroughly enjoyed it. It was very spicy and I loved every bite. My other friends ordered these loaded quesadilla's (she's vegetarian) and mac n' cheese, and both of the dishes were impressive to look at and taste.
For a 'dive bar,' I have yet to find better bar food. I highly recommend Mickey's Tavern!