After dropping Gotham (because the owner was a total d--k), I made my way back to Bagels Forever. Now I'm a regular. I usually pick up a dozen at time, slice and freeze them. They aren't the biggest or the chewiest bagels but they're pretty good. I usually pick them up in the morning so I ALWAYs grab a breakfast sandwich. Beats the hell out any of the chain muffin-type b'fast sammies. I walk out for less than $10. Their lunch sandwiches are pretty damn (inexpensive) good too.
Friendly quick, no bull. I am a fan!