We have been caking it up with fancy cakes from Carl since 2009. The quality of his cakes are absolutely superior. The prices are a bit high but since you are getting the best cake in the Madison metro area, I suppose he kind of gets to determine the market since he has no real competition. The only negative I have is that my daughter's birthday is in mid June and the city of Sun Prairie shuts down all the streets around the store location for some stupid street festival. Generally I have to park about seven blocks away, usually illegally, and lug two giant cakes back to the car. But I won't downgrade Carl for that. City of Sun Prairie on the other hand, gets 2 stars our of 5.