I'm SO glad I didn't listen to most of these bad reviews. I was scared to try 8th Ave. pizza, BUT I tried it in March 2013 and I've ordered a lot of pizzas from here ever since and they are always FANTASTIC. I'm extremely picky and pretty sensitive to pizza; 8th Ave. pizza doesn't ever upset my stomach. The ingredients are very fresh tasting and I have never gotten a greasy one, we order pepperoni, mushroom and green bell pepper. The crust is the thinner chewy with a slight crisp type. This pizza is definitely a pleaser and not like cardboard at all. I am very picky and highly recommend 8th Ave. Pizza. We are regulars and can't stand the national chains.
P.S. the pizzas are NY style (thin crust).