The $5 lunch deal is a lot of awesome food - why would anyone go to the Subway next door? Because of the popularity of the lunch deal, they're usually super busy during lunch hours. No matter how long you have to wait though, you'll always get friendly service.
All of their breads are freshly made and you can't go wrong with any of them. I've tried the wheat, ciabatta and sour dough and they're all really good.
My co-workers and I go there about once a week and we all love the Hell's Kitchen, Chicken Salad, Tuna Salad and of course the Turkey sandwiches, so I'd definitely recommend any of those.