I had to score right down the middle because first, I love their food. Quite a big menu that makes decision making a bit difficult but I have never had a complaint with any selection I made. The turkey burger (whichever way you want it) is my favorite. Their poutine appetizer is pretty much as good as it gets, which makes it something I most always get upon visit.
The loss of stars is for the beer. I'm not particularly fond of any of their brews, but that doesn't mean they aren't something I'll drink while I'm there (no other choice if you want beer). Though the beer isn't terrible I'm just not impressed. Wisconsin has so many better beer choices it is a let down to have such an uninspiring selection to go with such fantastic food.