For starters, I've been to Pie Town several times. It is a very convenient place in which to meet friends after work.
I'll start with what I like:
I love their Moscato wine. YUM! However, the downside... It costs $15 a glass. Way too expensive if you want to have 2 - 3 glasses - the bottle price isn't any better! I believe it is $69. I guess I have great taste in wine!
I have tried Calamari many times and I hate it! It is just nasty and rubbery and everyone serves it with marinara. However, at Pie Town, I love their Calamari. I can taste a tiny bit of lemon juice, but they put this sauce on the Calamari that is out of this world. It is very light and tastes very good. Their Calamari is not rubbery and the food is hot when they bring it to your table.
I had eaten there the other night and had 2 slices of pizza left over that I had asked to be boxed up for me. Apparently, while boxing up the leftovers, they accidentally dropped the pizza. When the server told me about this, he also stated that they had already created a duplicate pizza for me and was currently in the oven. So, their service is great!
What I don't much like:
The pizzas are not that great. They have great variety, but definitely not the best pizza I've ever had. I had the shrimp scampi pizza - shrimp too sweet for pizza. The pizza/shrimp should have been spicy since it was a shrimp scampi pizza.
Their desserts are expensive for what you get.
Downside is pricing and quality of main course meals (pizza pies)