This place is incredibly addicting! My favorite flavor is Muddle: chocolate ice cream with caramel and Oreos, it's life-changing!
Unfortunately they ran out one night but let me know they could make a suitable replacement by adding caramel to the chocolate and Oreo ice cream. Sounds great in theory, but my server added a peanut butter sauce instead... thank goodness I'm not allergic to peanut butter, but I don't like the taste at all and it tainted the rest of the ice cream. :(
But clearly I've put that night behind me and continue to frequent the creamery, it's addicting! I just make sure to keep the delicious ice cream topping-less, it doesn't need any additions.